| AFC |
| Team | Player(s) |
| Baltimore (6) | Jacoby Jones, kick returner *-Vonta Leach, fullback Haloti Ngata, interior lineman *-Ed Reed, free safety Ray Rice, running back *-Marshal Yanda, guard |
| Cincinnati (2) | *-Geno Atkins, interior lineman *-A.J. Green, wide receiver |
| Cleveland (2) | Phil Dawson, placekicker *-Joe Thomas, offensive tackle |
| Denver (5) | *-Champ Bailey, cornerback Ryan Clady, tackle Elvis Dumervil, defensive end *-Peyton Manning, quarterback *-Von Miller, outside linebacker |
| Houston (8) | *-Duane Brown, tackle *-Arian Foster, running back *-Andre Johnson, wide receiver *-Johnathan Joseph, cornerback Chris Myers, center Matt Schaub, quarterback Wade Smith, guard *-J.J. Watt, defensive end |
| Indianapolis (2) | Robert Mathis, outside linebacker Reggie Wayne, wide receiver |
| Kansas City (5) | *-Eric Berry, strong safety Jamaal Charles, running back Dustin Colquitt, punter *-Tamba Hali, outside linebacker Derrick Johnson, inside/middle linebacker |
| Miami (1) | *-Cameron Wake, defensive end |
| New England (7) | Tom Brady, quarterback *-Rob Gronkowski, tight end *-Logan Mankins, guard *-Jerod Mayo, inside/middle linebacker Matthew Slater, special-teamer Wes Welker, wide receiver *-Vince Wilfork, interior lineman |
| N.Y. Jets (2) | Antonio Cromartie, cornerback LaRon Landry, strong safety |
| Pittsburgh (2) | Heath Miller, tight end *-Maurkice Pouncey, center |
| |
| NFC |
| Team | Player(s) |
| Arizona (1) | Patrick Peterson, cornerback |
| Atlanta (3) | *-Tony Gonzalez, tight end Julio Jones, wide receiver Matt Ryan, quarterback |
| Chicago (5) | *-Tim Jennings, cornerback *-Brandon Marshall, wide receiver *-Henry Melton, interior lineman *-Julius Peppers, defensive end *-Charles Tillman, cornerback |
| Dallas (2) | *-DeMarcus Ware, outside linebacker Jason Witten, tight end |
| Detroit (1) | *-Calvin Johnson, wide receiver |
| Green Bay (3) | Clay Matthews, outside linebacker *-Aaron Rodgers, quarterback Jeff Saturday, center |
| Minnesota (4) | Jared Allen, defensive end *-Jerome Felton, fullback *-Adrian Peterson, running back Blair Walsh, placekicker |
| New Orleans (2) | *-Jahri Evans, guard Thomas Morstead, punter |
| N.Y. Giants (3) | Victor Cruz, wide receiver *-Jason Pierre-Paul, defensive end Chris Snee, guard |
| San Francisco (9) | NaVorro Bowman, inside/middle linebacker *-Dashon Goldson, free safety Frank Gore, running back *-Mike Iupati, guard *-Aldon Smith, outside linebacker *-Justin Smith, interior lineman *-Joe Staley, tackle *-Donte Whitner, strong safety *-Patrick Willis, inside/middle linebacker |
| Seattle (5) | Marshawn Lynch, running back *-Russell Okung, tackle Earl Thomas, free safety *-Max Unger, center Leon Washington, kick returner |
| Tampa Bay (1) | Gerald McCoy, interior lineman |
| Washington (3) | Lorenzo Alexander, special-teamer Robert Griffin III, quarterback Trent Williams, tackle |
|